Mooooooore skeptism

Please bear with me. My boy, Max, posted here a while ago, in regards to me, and he's trying to push me more into having conversations with others about my own doubts with multiplicity.

When I was young, I began studying other religions, and I really became interested in spirituallity. Along the way, I discovered two others living within. Really, this is just background information, so no know thinks I'm trying to troll or rag on the community. I've been aware of my own multiplicity for a number of years. I also see my multiplicity as a means to my own personal spirituallity. That is, I don't have a set religion, but I see the presence of and communication with my system as being a self-enlightening, holy experience.

I see this huge resurgance of multiples on the internet, and it makes me skeptical. NOT, because of the fact that their multiples. I wouldn't call someone out on being a "fake". But, the way some of these systems carry on, it makes me wonder how they can reasonably function.

I'm going to point the finger at soulbonding, because it seems to be the means of multiplicity that houses the greatest number of loonies. I can accept, per se, that another has entered your system, and is a bad influence, and perhaps is forcing your body and system down a bad path. I can not, however, accept that this entity causing harm is, say, Sephiroth from the Final Fantasy games. That, is insane. Final Fantasy is fiction. It may very well be an entity that projects images OF Sephiroth into your mind, but part of gaining some feasible aspect of functional control over yourselves, is seeing through the bullshit.

I have trouble with people who play INTO that bullshit, by extension. Not only do they seem to be the loudest group of loons, but they're also impossible to have a reasonable discussion with. Everything boils down to "it's different for everyone", which is great for upholding any kind of deluded fantasy that you might have, but really, isn't productive for conversation.

Especially...if you're attempting to learn something, or see if they have a reason to act the way that they do.

Are there any rational, sane soulbonds, here? If so, do they honestly believe that they're fictional characters? This seems to be the most levelheaded community about plurality on LJ that we can find, so I figure it would be the best place to start.

[identity profile] shadowechoes.livejournal.com 2005-08-10 05:37 am (UTC)(link)
I guess our opinion of soulbounds is that they aren't the actual fictional character, but possibly a system member who has been shaped or shaped themselves into the image/personality of a fictional character to varying degrees (at least in the case of soulbounders who have other peoples' characters in their system). We're not really comfortable with the alternate universe theory since I think a lot of authors just make up their characters, or at least we do when we make characters for stories or RPs. There's a whole editting and planning/shaping process - one that we definitely couldn't mistake for "having a connetion to a (similar) person in an alternate reality). Our charaters are just fiction, and I'd laugh if anyone showed up with them as a soulbond (not that anyone knows of any of our characters since it's not like we're some famous author or anything) since they would really have no idea of the history behind not only the character but the creation process of the character. Hmm, make any sense?

As for soulbonders who bond to characters they created themselves, we see that as more of the creation of a type of system member. Just like some systems can split for various reasons or create people to have purposes in the system or whatnot, I think creativity can create and develop full people in systems whether they're acknowledged as a person, a soulbond, or just a character. Some may be more along the lines of I guess a median or midcontinum if those are the right terms I'm thinking of, but anyway hopefully that makes sense too.